You talk about a negotiated deal being "short sighted" -- assuming the only possible deal involves turning over complete control of the HS to Iran -- which I don't accept.
But OK, I'd like to hear your 'long-term view' of what happens if the U.S. begins a ground war in Iran. Best case AND worst case scenarios, because as you know things rarely proceed as planned in the fog of war.
First...you and I aren't on opposite sides of this issue. We're on opposite sides of the solution.
Best case scenario...
Send small (relative to the size of our conventional ground forces), dedicated special forces units to take out military leadership and critical military infrastructure that's being used to make drones, launch rockets, lay mines, and disrupt shipping. These units are truly elite, it's what they've trained for their whole lives, and those people are generally very willing to do what they've been trained to do. Much more so than a bunch of 22 year old infantrymen who signed up to pay for college or because they want to do one term and join the National Guard for the retirement. This would not need to be at the scale of an Iraq 1990/2003 invasion. Not even close. 5,000-6,000 soldiers/SEALs/airmen tops with the best military equipment on the planet at their disposal.
Most of these things are frustratingly difficult or impossible to attack or destroy remotely by sea/air. They're small drone/missile factories etc. that Iran puts in the middle of cities and civilian places. Iran's military is nothing without the leadership, and we saw the same thing in Iraq with the mass defections in '90 and '03 once the military command started falling. Do you remember the hordes of Iraqi soldiers walking through the desert to surrender en masse? Their regulars don't want to be in a fight like this, but if they don't do what the man says, you can imagine what will happen to them. Iran already doesn't have a standing navy or air force, they are reduced to little boats throwing mines in the sea and mobile rocket launchers. And that's all they need because
as long as there's a threat, shipping comes to a halt. If all the sudden 200 tankers set sail to transport oil there's no way Iran could stop more than a few, but threat of taking a chance at it is what has stopped all these ships and driven insurance to an impossible level regardless.
I truly feel that a politically competent president who listens to capable military advisors can, and would, be able to do this and be successful. Be it GW or Obama. I'm not getting into the Republican vs. Democrat debate...but I do know that either of those presidents would've been able to navigate this. I don't think either of them would've gotten us to this point, but had they been presented with this situation they would be able to navigate it like I described above.
Worst case scnario...
Trump deciding that he's a lame duck anyway, and wanting to go full WW2 D-day to show everyone what he can do. With a false sense of "I'm the overlord of the world and we're going to delete this country off the map." He reaches a point where a year from now gas is $6.00 a gallon, diesel is $11.00 and even the upper middle class can't survive the inflation domino effect so he feels backed in a corner to do something. Netanyahu is hoping for this one and might just get it.
He loves shock and awe, and something like that will do nothing but draw China into the fight, kill thousands of civilians, and leave a country so ruined that it needs occupation for the next 20 years.
I'm not suggesting nor promoting full blown war. There are ways to do this effectively if Trump would trust the military, non-yes men in charge and let them do their jobs the most effective way possible. Unfortunately he's either fired all of them or let them resign because they couldn't in good conscious work for him.
So where does that leave us? My guess is somewhere in between. As I said, a negotiated settlement leaves the US truly powerless. Who's to say Iran doesn't reneg later and here we sit again if they get mad at us? There's no bluff for them to call anymore...They always have China to partner with and China is much more than willing to do so and take over the world driver's seat. Chamberlain and Joe Kennedy had the same mindset as what you're suggesting before WW2 and thankfully Roosevelt and Churchill knew that sitting back and walking away would put the wrong powers in place permanently. Is this WW2? No. There's no Hitler here exterminating Jews and trying to take over the world. We're not being bombed in Hawaii...but the point is the same and the stakes are high. People just don't realize that energy is what makes the world go 'round unfortunately. More than money or anything else. If you control the supply of energy, you control everything. Because if you can choke a country off long enough it's going to snowball to the point where everything stops functioning.
If Iran and China decide they want diesel in the US to be $12.00 a gallon they can make it happen. Would it cause them short term pain? Sure. But they also know it'd be temporary and the juice would be worth the squeeze. Flights would stop. Driving would stop. Groceries would become completely unaffordable. Farmers wouldn't be able to run planters or combines and then guess what happens to your ability to buy food. No vacations, no going out for supper, no sports to watch, no industries would be untouched. You think China and Iran don't know this? Once China draws their reserves all the way down do you really think they're just going to play nice and tell Iran to start letting oil through to be nice? What easier way to take Taiwan than to wait until the US is in such dire straits that it can't put any effort there? This is the opportunity they've been waiting for and they're sitting back waiting in the weeds to pounce on it. Don't take my word for it...there are plenty of well-respected economists on every part of the political spectrum warning people about the same thing. Look for yourself.