Take-aways

1. The game was much closer than the score indicates. The program has nothing to be embarrassed about.

2. During the bye week, I hope the coaches take a hard look at center and left guard. Winters and Jones were flat-out abused all game long.

3. It sounds strange to say it, but we actually did a good job on Smith. The one long TD was right after Lutmer went down, and they isolated him on Hawkins. On the other long catch and run, the coverage was great. Wallace was in great position and his finger tips were literally 1-2 inches from the ball. Smith benefited from being behind Wallace and the safety when all three went for the ball.

4. Ries needs to start over Montgomery. Montgomery's athletic limitations hurt us against the better teams. He gets overwhelmed in the run game, and doesn't have enough speed to cover.

5. Brown made a few nice throws, but also was way off several times to open receivers, and, obviously, the fumble on the first drive shouldn't have happened. Just not a smart play. Heck isn't perfect, but I still feel he has the higher ceiling.

6. The illegal formation call on the last drive before halftime was an absolute killer, and changed the complete complexion of the game. It was the difference between going into halftime either up 13-10 or down 10-9, versus down 17-6. HUGE call.

7. Hopefully, the injuries aren't serious, with Lutmer's being the most concerning. If Lee can't go, I hope they give Darion Jones a shot. He's got big-time upside.
Definitely agree We made mistakes the others usually do. Turnovers, O line penalties and the ball bouncing in the other guy's favor is our way . It just went the other way yesterday and they are a better team.
 
1. The game was much closer than the score indicates. The program has nothing to be embarrassed about.

2. During the bye week, I hope the coaches take a hard look at center and left guard. Winters and Jones were flat-out abused all game long.

3. It sounds strange to say it, but we actually did a good job on Smith. The one long TD was right after Lutmer went down, and they isolated him on Hawkins. On the other long catch and run, the coverage was great. Wallace was in great position and his finger tips were literally 1-2 inches from the ball. Smith benefited from being behind Wallace and the safety when all three went for the ball.

4. Ries needs to start over Montgomery. Montgomery's athletic limitations hurt us against the better teams. He gets overwhelmed in the run game, and doesn't have enough speed to cover.

5. Brown made a few nice throws, but also was way off several times to open receivers, and, obviously, the fumble on the first drive shouldn't have happened. Just not a smart play. Heck isn't perfect, but I still feel he has the higher ceiling.

6. The illegal formation call on the last drive before halftime was an absolute killer, and changed the complete complexion of the game. It was the difference between going into halftime either up 13-10 or down 10-9, versus down 17-6. HUGE call.

7. Hopefully, the injuries aren't serious, with Lutmer's being the most concerning. If Lee can't go, I hope they give Darion Jones a shot. He's got big-time upside.
Good post and I agree with all of your points. I will add a couple of things.

On #2, if Winters is struggling so much I wonder if they have considered moving Pieper over to Center and getting someone else (Allgeyer?) at right guard? Just a thought. I do think Jones will get things figured out.

On #7, you probably know now but Lutmer and Lee both had cramping issues so that is good news. I do agree on Darion Jones. He is really good on special teams and reminds me a little of Bob Sanders in that regard.

My last thoughts are on the quarterback position. I do think Hank has earned the starting job. But with that said, Heck looked pretty darned good yesterday in a short stint. I do believe if Hanks struggles Heck should get a shot, even if just in relief. Remember, yesterday was the first time Heck got to be in a P4 game with the first teamers all the weapons at his disposal. He looked sharp. I also understand that each QB can look like an NFL starter one day and a Division III backup the next. But my point is that Lester should keep an open mind and not be afraid to make a move if the situation warrants it.
 
Good post and I agree with all of your points. I will add a couple of things.

On #2, if Winters is struggling so much I wonder if they have considered moving Pieper over to Center and getting someone else (Allgeyer?) at right guard? Just a thought. I do think Jones will get things figured out.

On #7, you probably know now but Lutmer and Lee both had cramping issues so that is good news. I do agree on Darion Jones. He is really good on special teams and reminds me a little of Bob Sanders in that regard.

My last thoughts are on the quarterback position. I do think Hank has earned the starting job. But with that said, Heck looked pretty darned good yesterday in a short stint. I do believe if Hanks struggles Heck should get a shot, even if just in relief. Remember, yesterday was the first time Heck got to be in a P4 game with the first teamers all the weapons at his disposal. He looked sharp. I also understand that each QB can look like an NFL starter one day and a Division III backup the next. But my point is that Lester should keep an open mind and not be afraid to make a move if the situation warrants it.
Agree but as we know with the last point on qb, it’s Ferentz and only ferentz that matters. The track record speaks for itself
 
The Line on both sides of the ball......???. We are not there, but we just played a couple of teams that have lines that are top ten their money can buy. And this is what we have, not much there to change other than some schemes maybe? They will get better and more confidence after we play some teams that are at our level. And will be playing good in November. WE need receivers to get open down field like always, and that wasn't happening either. More coverage sacks than bad line play. Now in the run game NO we didn't push people around like we are used to. but once again we should match up good with all the teams we have left. There are no miracle solutions just week by week improvements.......We've all been here before its how we roll !!

ON HAWKS
 
The longest run from scrimmage for Iowa during ISU, UM and OSU was 11 yards. It happened yesterday by LJ Phillips against OSU. They had 1 of 9 yards against UM and 1 of 8 yards against ISU.

My take away is that we're looking at 2022 / 2023 rushing production numbers.
 
Last edited:
Good post and I agree with all of your points. I will add a couple of things.

On #2, if Winters is struggling so much I wonder if they have considered moving Pieper over to Center and getting someone else (Allgeyer?) at right guard? Just a thought. I do think Jones will get things figured out.

On #7, you probably know now but Lutmer and Lee both had cramping issues so that is good news. I do agree on Darion Jones. He is really good on special teams and reminds me a little of Bob Sanders in that regard.

My last thoughts are on the quarterback position. I do think Hank has earned the starting job. But with that said, Heck looked pretty darned good yesterday in a short stint. I do believe if Hanks struggles Heck should get a shot, even if just in relief. Remember, yesterday was the first time Heck got to be in a P4 game with the first teamers all the weapons at his disposal. He looked sharp. I also understand that each QB can look like an NFL starter one day and a Division III backup the next. But my point is that Lester should keep an open mind and not be afraid to make a move if the situation warrants it.
I doubt they will make any significant changes along the OL, but moving Dotzler to LG and starting Bodey McCaslin at RT would be interesting. I'm not convinced that Jones will "get things figured out." He is simply getting overpowered. That's not going to change quickly.

I think they are pretty stuck with Winter. Myslinski hasn't had much of a chance to develop due to chronic injury issues, and I doubt Pieper has had significant reps at center.
 
I also understand that each QB can look like an NFL starter one day and a Division III backup the next. But my point is that Lester should keep an open mind and not be afraid to make a move if the situation warrants it.
The trick is making that switch before it’s too late
 
Sometimes it's easier to see and analyze things by watching on TV, but here are my major takeaways from being close to the field at Kinnick:
* the penalty for lining up wrong with 4 min remaining in the 1st half was critical. Despite having spotted OSU with a TD the first 2 min of the game, without that penalty the Hawks were 1st and 10 on the OSU 40, and would likely have gone into halftime down only 10-9 -- with a VERY jacked up crowd. Instead, that OSU drive just before half (which seemed to be largely on the ground) sucked all the air out of Kinnick, and pretty much any hope of pulling an upset for the ages. The crowd was basically dead for the rest of the day.
* Parker was incredibly stubborn by refusing to put more than 4 DLinemen at the LOS during that drive -- committing to neither stopping the run OR pressuring their QB. Extremely frustrating in the moment!
* QB Brown had a REALLY bad day. The first couple drives were good: quick throws to the outside, complimented by some nice throws into the middle of the field. But then it became clear he wasn't real sharp with any other type of throw, and I can't even count how many open WRs he missed on longish out-routes toward the sideline. Guys were open.
* At the start of the 2nd half, the D did their part, getting 2 stops. The Offense did....nothing. On 3 consecutive offensive plays, Iowa had receivers wide open, and Brown missed all 3 of them -- badly.
* Teams now have the formula for completely stopping Iowa's run game -- by simply putting 5 guys on the LOS. It ain't rocket science. This not only stops Iowa's run game, it gives them the option of rushing an extra guy if it's not a run play -- and yesterday Iowa's OL of 5 guys had trouble blocking OSU's FOUR. This formula puts a ton of pressure on Brown, who was very indecisive yesterday.
* By the end of the 3rd quarter, Iowa had a grand total of 161 yds of offense. That it took an injury to remove Brown from the game is a sobering reminder of how reluctant KF is to give the backup Qb a chance.
* I understand that WR #4 Smith is a great talent. But my gosh, it was shocking to see how many times Parker let him line up 1-on-1 vs Iowa's CBs -- I mean, what would you EXPECT to happen? Why not double-team him with a CB and Safety, bump him at the LOS, ride him 5 yds every single freaking play and make somebody ELSE beat you??
* By the end of the game, Iowa was playing guys that haven't seen the field with the 1st team all season: #20 Hudkins (?) at Safety, #18 at Safety, #84 at DE...it was like a team of backups in the DBackfield when CB Lee went out, and OSU could have named their score -- they simply ran out the clock, but make no mistake, with that DBackfield lineup on the field, OSU could have scored 2 TDs in that time period rather than just run out the clock.
 
I think if Iowa plays that team in Kinnick 10 times, we win 3 of them. The talent gap was not as big as I thought it would be. We needed to play an incredibly clean game and we just didn't. But, we were not run off the field by any stretch. I liked the game plan on both sides of the ball. We needed better play at QB, RB and interior OL and that would have been a pretty even game.
 
I will echo what others said about the penalty and allowing OSU to score at the end of the half. That was the turning point in the game. Before that, I was gacked up, texting hard with my boys and feeling like we were playing these guys straight up after spotting them a TD. Wind went right out of my sail at the end of the half. D put up a decent fight in the 3rd quarter, but with no help from the O, it was pretty hard to keep OSU out of the endzone.
 
I will echo what others said about the penalty and allowing OSU to score at the end of the half. That was the turning point in the game. Before that, I was gacked up, texting hard with my boys and feeling like we were playing these guys straight up after spotting them a TD. Wind went right out of my sail at the end of the half. D put up a decent fight in the 3rd quarter, but with no help from the O, it was pretty hard to keep OSU out of the endzone.
Exactly how I felt!
 
Here's a takeaway nobody is gonna like.

The playoffs suck. And should involve ONLY the conference winners. Fix the conferences if necessary.
Iowa could win out. Indiana and the rest beat up on each other and lose 2 conference games.
Iowa could go to Indy, play OSU and:
-lose by a ton (and rightfully....maybe....DEPENDING on all other games/teams) be out of the playoffs
-lose by 1 point on a flukey last minute, extra second put back on the clock play and POSSIBLY (rightfully) be out of the playoffs.

The every growing intensity of the "national title" is bad for college football.
The Championship should be the Poptart Bowl. Winners get a trophy, some Poptarts and all TV money is split with all other teams who make bowl games. The NC participants get no extra money. Just a year's supply of poptarts. The playoffs should be conference champions only.

All the other bowl games should be more fun and sillier than the Poptart Bowl.
If they can't be more fun than the Poptart Bowl, they need to end. That will cut down on some of the useless ones. With fewer bowl games, they might mean a bit more. Participants get the money from the bowls AND a share of the NC title game revenues.
 
We had a very narrow window to win and the breaks had to go our way. They sacked our QB, he fumbled, and they got the ball at the 15. We sacked their QB, made him fumble, and we didn't get it. OP is right, the killer was the penalty with 2 min to go in the half. Was it Lauck or Dotzler, does anyone know? If it was Dotzler, he had the 2 worst penalties in this game that directly contributed to 14 points for OSU and a possible 17 or 21 point swing.

At the end of the day though OSU is a terrible mismatch for us. We have average corners, average pass rushers, a non-mobile QB and we had a safety out (Brown). How you beat OSU is to be able to man up their receivers long enough to get to Sayin with your pass rush, and on the other side is to be able to have the QB extend some plays with his legs and spread them out enough to lighten the box.

One thing I really liked was the one drive with Heck at QB. I am not saying there should be a controversy or anything, Hank has done well and earned the job. But Heck was sharp, decisive and got the ball out. And don't think that OSU was letting us have that, they had their starters in and were wanting to finish. What Heck did is what I am sure TL wants his offense to look like. Hank looked indecisive, inaccurate and everything looked slow and sloppy. I think for this game in particular, Heck was a better fit than Hank because of what OSU was going to do to stack the box.

I agree. I was actually going to start a thread on Heck vs Hank. It's a weird situation. The inconsistency from Hank or both has really got to be driving Ferentz and Lester nuts.

I realize the game was over when Heck got in but I also saw how decisive and good his passes were. They were right on target and not all of them were easy pitches to receivers. He had a couple to the sideline that were defended pretty well and he hit. He was just very decisive and accurate. The ball just seemed to flow out of his hand effortlessly and spot on.

Yes, Hank had his moment with VDZ for the Michigan win and it was terrific, but one has to wonder if Heck was the QB, if they would not have needed a last second pass for a win. Could have Heck gotten them an extra TD or two? Will never know.

Maybe it would be good to roll with Heck and use his legs more to move the ball on drives. This could loosen up the D & possibly help the run game if the D had to honor the QB running. If he were to get hurt, you always have Hank there and not lose much. Hell, you also have Sullivan who can't be that far behind and have Bessinger who might have the best arm of all if would get down to him but prob not the case.
 
I think if Iowa plays that team in Kinnick 10 times, we win 3 of them. The talent gap was not as big as I thought it would be. We needed to play an incredibly clean game and we just didn't. But, we were not run off the field by any stretch. I liked the game plan on both sides of the ball. We needed better play at QB, RB and interior OL and that would have been a pretty even game.
I knew when Hank got hit and lost the ball on the first drive, it would be an uphill battle Iowa wouldn't be able to overcome yesterday. If that doesn't happen and Iowa was able to drive a bit and pin Ohio St back on their side of the field, who knows how the game would have gone. It just sucked losing that ball on the first drive, after taking the ball to keep Ohio St's offense off the field. It only works if your team can grind out some yrds and 7-8 minutes of clock.
 
I knew when Hank got hit and lost the ball on the first drive, it would be an uphill battle Iowa wouldn't be able to overcome yesterday. If that doesn't happen and Iowa was able to drive a bit and pin Ohio St back on their side of the field, who knows how the game would have gone. It just sucked losing that ball on the first drive, after taking the ball to keep Ohio St's offense off the field. It only works if your team can grind out some yrds and 7-8 minutes of clock.
I liked that Iowa overcame that initial blunder and it was a tight game going into the end of the half. I was excited. Then I wasn't. We could have gone into half time 9-10 that would have been huge. Even 9-13. Grrrrr
 
Anyone think OSU was letting up a little when Heck was in there?

No. it was still early in the 4th quarter and you could tell by Day's reaction he was not happy. Hecklinski not only threw sharper passes, be the offense just appeared to look a little quicker than with Brown in the game.

For the record, I really like Kirk Ferentz as Iowa's coach, although during the Brian years I did not, and hope he stays on for as long as his passion remains. He seems to me to be enjoying game days at the very least quite a bit and Iowa could do much worse, as we've seen with other programs who change coaches frequently. Don't fix what ain't broke.

With that said, This year I don't see Iowa winning more than 9 games total and likely only 8 during the regular season. The o-line just isn't that good right now and the d-line isn't that good either.
 
Both lines are very average and Hecklinski should be QB. Throws a better ball with some mustard on it. Will never happen unless Brown truly hurt. Seen 25+ years to know that answer
 
Top