IowaLaw's Post Game Analysis: Penn State

IowaLawWasRight

Well-Known Member
Two tough losses in 7 days will drop Iowa out of the national conversation, but is all lost? Both games were against top 15 teams, and both games were winnable up until the final seconds. Based on the talent level on this roster, Iowa will still be favored to win each remaining game on the schedule except for Wisconsin.

1. Koerner. The walk-on Dowling Maroon shouldn't be out there this early in his career in this big of a matchup on national tv...but he is. He doesn't have the athleticism needed to stay with the KJ Hamlers of this world, but guess what? He produces. Koerner was all over the field and finished with 13 tackles. Rather than playing for his next best scholarship offer, UNI, Koerner has become a leader on the defense and is improving every week. Seriously, though, what happened in recruiting to have a walk-on sophomore playing such an important role on defense?

2. Paulson Busts. As IowaLaw predicted in his pre-season analysis, the huge recruiting win 6 years ago landing the Paulsons, monstrous 6'6 twins from small town Iowa has worked out much like the career of all world recruit Blake Larson decades ago. They have spent 5 years in the system under Doyle's "famous" strength training and Kirk's "OL guru" coaching, yet they and their interior line cohorts block like Spanish bull fighters whiffing as opposing DL routinely come unblocked straight into Iowa's backfield. Behind the Paulsons on the depth chart, Iowa's recruiting failures have been so pronounced that the OL relies solely upon freshmen like Cody Ince and Jeff Jenkins who can't be expected to block a team like Penn State to block next to a freshmen center. Shame on the coaches for such monumental recruiting failures at OL University, where we have no problem recruiting this position.

3. Smith & Smith-Marsette. Combined for 12 catches for 160 yards, these two start who, as freshmen, were liabilities, are now the strengths of the offense (again, that goes back to poor recruiting and forcing freshmen to play when they are not ready). Aside from the solid numbers, Smith & Smith-Marsette are showing a kind of moxie that the team so desperately lacks from its cub scout quarterback. If these guys continue the improvement, they could be legit all-Big 10 caliber play makers next year.

4. Golston. Week in and week out, under-the-radar Golston has proven himself to be the best DE on the field. This week, he finished with 8 tackles, including 1.5 for a loss. Not only was he getting pressure on the QB, but he wasn't taking himself out of plays by solely relying on rushing on the outside of the pocket (a problem of AJE) and helped stuff the run. Golston could be benefiting from extra attention placed on AJE, but he's making the most of it.

5. Stanley. Having the game on the line in back to back weeks on national tv against blue blood opponents is the thing of most QB's dreams growing up. Unfortunately, the same thoughts are what caused Stanley to wet the bed until the 4th grade. His numbers continue to be mediocre, 25/43 for 286 yards 1 td and 1 int, but his misses to open receivers on huge 3rd downs were so bad this week that to say he was randying around would not do the term justice. He routinely placed balls behind WRs, and his brainy "academic all-Big 10" audibles continue to be runs up the middle 100% of the time, leading to the RB getting stuffed in the background. Stanley's audible led to Goodson getting drilled in the backfield for a fumble that cost Iowa the game this week. While most 3rd year starters have mastered the run pass option, Kirk has kept that out of Stanley's limited playbook. Kudos to the A- in phys ed class, though, Nate.
 
Koerner's 13 tackles were as empty a stat as Stanley's 286 passing yards. He missed some tackles in critical situations, including one that kept Penn States final drive alive.

If Merriweather is back healthy, this position may be to be revisited.

Eppy got at least one sack by bull rushing right over the OT, who was then forced into several penalties, including holding on the goaline. Iowa, with help from the officials, ended up forcing a field goal.
 
Stanley's the problem, riiiiggghhhttt. So, if you fake play action and turn around and a 290 DT has gone unblocked and is right in your face, that's Stanley's fault? Is Stanley supposed to coldcock him with his left hand and throw with his right.

Our interior offensive line play is awful...and it's just not the Paulsons. There were several mental mistakes on the OLine and guys just flat out whiffing on blocks in the passing and running game...until you see some improvement and consistency...this offense stalls.
 
Stanley's the problem, riiiiggghhhttt. So, if you fake play action and turn around and a 290 DT has gone unblocked and is right in your face, that's Stanley's fault? Is Stanley supposed to coldcock him with his left hand and throw with his right.

Our interior offensive line play is awful...and it's just not the Paulsons. There were several mental mistakes on the OLine and guys just flat out whiffing on blocks in the passing and running game...until you see some improvement and consistency...this offense stalls.

I was watching one of the sports yelling shows the other day and one of the arguer guys was a former NFL player, Chris Canty I think and he said there are 2 types of QBs. Guys who elevate the players around them and guys who maintain the players around them. Nate is definitely a maintain type of QB. He just doesn't have the ability to make up for other's mistakes.
 
Stanley's the problem, riiiiggghhhttt. So, if you fake play action and turn around and a 290 DT has gone unblocked and is right in your face, that's Stanley's fault? Is Stanley supposed to coldcock him with his left hand and throw with his right.

Our interior offensive line play is awful...and it's just not the Paulsons. There were several mental mistakes on the OLine and guys just flat out whiffing on blocks in the passing and running game...until you see some improvement and consistency...this offense stalls.

Correct, we do not have a very big play offense so to have successful drives there can be hardly any penalties and even hardly any negative plays. A loss of 2 on first down can be a driver killer. Without the big run and catch TEnds this year it is hard to get first downs.

It was good to see Weiting make a couple of big catches and hope that can continue.
 
Two tough losses in 7 days will drop Iowa out of the national conversation, but is all lost? Both games were against top 15 teams, and both games were winnable up until the final seconds. Based on the talent level on this roster, Iowa will still be favored to win each remaining game on the schedule except for Wisconsin.

1. Koerner. The walk-on Dowling Maroon shouldn't be out there this early in his career in this big of a matchup on national tv...but he is. He doesn't have the athleticism needed to stay with the KJ Hamlers of this world, but guess what? He produces. Koerner was all over the field and finished with 13 tackles. Rather than playing for his next best scholarship offer, UNI, Koerner has become a leader on the defense and is improving every week. Seriously, though, what happened in recruiting to have a walk-on sophomore playing such an important role on defense?

2. Paulson Busts. As IowaLaw predicted in his pre-season analysis, the huge recruiting win 6 years ago landing the Paulsons, monstrous 6'6 twins from small town Iowa has worked out much like the career of all world recruit Blake Larson decades ago. They have spent 5 years in the system under Doyle's "famous" strength training and Kirk's "OL guru" coaching, yet they and their interior line cohorts block like Spanish bull fighters whiffing as opposing DL routinely come unblocked straight into Iowa's backfield. Behind the Paulsons on the depth chart, Iowa's recruiting failures have been so pronounced that the OL relies solely upon freshmen like Cody Ince and Jeff Jenkins who can't be expected to block a team like Penn State to block next to a freshmen center. Shame on the coaches for such monumental recruiting failures at OL University, where we have no problem recruiting this position.

3. Smith & Smith-Marsette. Combined for 12 catches for 160 yards, these two start who, as freshmen, were liabilities, are now the strengths of the offense (again, that goes back to poor recruiting and forcing freshmen to play when they are not ready). Aside from the solid numbers, Smith & Smith-Marsette are showing a kind of moxie that the team so desperately lacks from its cub scout quarterback. If these guys continue the improvement, they could be legit all-Big 10 caliber play makers next year.

4. Golston. Week in and week out, under-the-radar Golston has proven himself to be the best DE on the field. This week, he finished with 8 tackles, including 1.5 for a loss. Not only was he getting pressure on the QB, but he wasn't taking himself out of plays by solely relying on rushing on the outside of the pocket (a problem of AJE) and helped stuff the run. Golston could be benefiting from extra attention placed on AJE, but he's making the most of it.

5. Stanley. Having the game on the line in back to back weeks on national tv against blue blood opponents is the thing of most QB's dreams growing up. Unfortunately, the same thoughts are what caused Stanley to wet the bed until the 4th grade. His numbers continue to be mediocre, 25/43 for 286 yards 1 td and 1 int, but his misses to open receivers on huge 3rd downs were so bad this week that to say he was randying around would not do the term justice. He routinely placed balls behind WRs, and his brainy "academic all-Big 10" audibles continue to be runs up the middle 100% of the time, leading to the RB getting stuffed in the background. Stanley's audible led to Goodson getting drilled in the backfield for a fumble that cost Iowa the game this week. While most 3rd year starters have mastered the run pass option, Kirk has kept that out of Stanley's limited playbook. Kudos to the A- in phys ed class, though, Nate.
Stanley throws where the receivers were, not where they are going, and isn't his thumb hurt, or was that last year's excuse?
 
Bottom line if the OL plays better we win that game. They were terrible for the 2nd week in a row and that shouldn’t happen, not on a KF team, if we have any chance to be good.

Agree, it's largely about the OL which affects the other moving parts on offense and agree this should not be happening with a Ferentz team. Not sure it's that correctable if we truly have a talent issue on the OL. Tempted to pile on with others because it is due but I'll hold out some hope (considering the remaining schedule) otherwise why even watch.
 
Northside - I'm a big proponent of the "empty stats" classification, especially when it comes to QB touchdown passes or time of possession. But in Koerner's case, 13 tackles is the most by ANY Hawkeye since Josey Jewell. While only 4 of his tackles were solo, he's a walk-on sophomore starting at a position where Iowa should be able to recruit 4 star after 4 star. Give the kid his due.

WinOne - Yup, Stanley's audible changing the play to a run up the middle (which all 85 scholarship players for Penn State telegraphed perfectly) was indeed the problem. There are tendencies, then there's Stanley and his audibles. Had he not showed his hand, Goodson doesn't get drilled in the backfield and Iowa may have won the game.

UIhawk - while you're right that the Hawks have been missing a big run and catch TE this year, I'm not sure it's because we lack the talent on the roster. Stanley simply has not been targeting the TEs for some reason. In the offseason, the staff said our TEs (Weiting, Cook, Beyer) are more than servicable. Weiting looks the part (6'4, 250, speed), but like with Oliver Martin, you can't make plays if the QB doesn't throw the ball your way.



Koerner's 13 tackles were as empty a stat as Stanley's 286 passing yards. He missed some tackles in critical situations, including one that kept Penn States final drive alive.

If Merriweather is back healthy, this position may be to be revisited.

Eppy got at least one sack by bull rushing right over the OT, who was then forced into several penalties, including holding on the goaline. Iowa, with help from the officials, ended up forcing a field goal.
 
Northside - I'm a big proponent of the "empty stats" classification, especially when it comes to QB touchdown passes or time of possession. But in Koerner's case, 13 tackles is the most by ANY Hawkeye since Josey Jewell. While only 4 of his tackles were solo, he's a walk-on sophomore starting at a position where Iowa should be able to recruit 4 star after 4 star. Give the kid his due.

WinOne - Yup, Stanley's audible changing the play to a run up the middle (which all 85 scholarship players for Penn State telegraphed perfectly) was indeed the problem. There are tendencies, then there's Stanley and his audibles. Had he not showed his hand, Goodson doesn't get drilled in the backfield and Iowa may have won the game.

UIhawk - while you're right that the Hawks have been missing a big run and catch TE this year, I'm not sure it's because we lack the talent on the roster. Stanley simply has not been targeting the TEs for some reason. In the offseason, the staff said our TEs (Weiting, Cook, Beyer) are more than servicable. Weiting looks the part (6'4, 250, speed), but like with Oliver Martin, you can't make plays if the QB doesn't throw the ball your way.

J Leman was a slow undersized kid who was a major part of a Sugar Bowl team. He had few solo tackles. He was not the Calibur of some IL famous on s. He was the local kid done good.

Still IL and IA should have had better recruits. Dallas Clark should have been practice squad with IA tight end expectations?

Would Clark have blossomed w o BB?

Guess you are both right?
 

Latest posts

Top