
Good to be in on him and he would be close to home. Not that ratings matter but, if he is the second rated QB on Rivals board, why isn't he a 5-star? I know not many get the coveted 5-star rating but you would think two QBs would get that distinction.
I am guessing they don't hand out a ton of 5 stars until they see some senior tape? Hold it back to see if that last star is deserved for great performances senior year?Was wondering the same thing. Maybe just a weak class? His highlights do look good...hitting tight windows, tons of deep balls on target.
I understand the skepticism and no one is handing him the Heisman. I would say that the difference between those guys and this guy, perhaps, will be who is coaching him.Petras was a 4* with massive HS numbers. Deuce Hogan was a 4*. Plenty of reasons to maintain skepticism, but it is never a bad thing to be in on a highly rated QB. One of them is going to hit, eventually.
I am a little more interested in recruiting than you, but I get your point.If I've learned anything by following recruiting in the NIL era, it's that you shouldn't follow recruiting in the NIL era.
All it takes is one bag and the warm and fuzzies get replaced by other warm and fuzzies. I don't start following players until they show up to camp.
I definitely don't follow it as close as I used to, but it's still fun to see who's even considering Iowa. But like you, I don't actually get excited about anyone until I see their name stitched on the jersey.If I've learned anything by following recruiting in the NIL era, it's that you shouldn't follow recruiting in the NIL era.
All it takes is one bag and the warm and fuzzies get replaced by other warm and fuzzies. I don't start following players until they show up to camp.
This is exactly right.I am guessing they don't hand out a ton of 5 stars until they see some senior tape? Hold it back to see if that last star is deserved for great performances senior year?
Injuries, regression, etc. They don't seem to like to downgrade stars.
I definitely don't follow it as close as I used to, but it's still fun to see who's even considering Iowa. But like you, I don't actually get excited about anyone until I see their name stitched on the jersey.
Yup. The day they physically set foot ON the practice field in uniform is when I believe any of it and then only for one season no matter how much they feign Hawkeye loyalty. The recruiting coverage gig is laughable these days but I understand the fascination for many fans looking for action.If I've learned anything by following recruiting in the NIL era, it's that you shouldn't follow recruiting in the NIL era.
All it takes is one bag and the warm and fuzzies get replaced by other warm and fuzzies. I don't start following players until they show up to camp.
NLIs got eliminated by the NCAA in 2024.I am a little more interested in recruiting than you, but I get your point.
Question: do kids still sign national letters of intent? Are they enforceable? It would seem to me that they are not since the NCAA currently allows unlimited transfers. But, curious if these documents have any relevance these days. It almost feels like these are one-way agreements. The school has to honor them for at least a year, but the kid could walk away the next day. Right?