My top 5 all time…
1) Tom Brands - Olympic gold, world championship, 3x national NCAA champ, 4x AA.
2) Ed Banach - same as above minus world championship. Career cut short by concussions and has CTE pretty bad, if he had had a chance to have a more extensive international career he would’ve been crazy.
3) Lincoln McIlravy - Olympic bronze, 2x world medalist, 3x national champ, 4x national finalist, 4x AA.
4) Terry Brands - Olympic bronze, 2x world champ, 2x NCAA national champ, 3x AA.
5) Spencer Lee - Olympic silver, 3x NCAA national champ, 4x AA.
Honorable mention: Randy Lewis. Got screwed by the Olympic boycott in 1980 and being in the same weight class as John Smith later on.
Guys with no international career are automatically excluded. Freestyle is what the rest of the planet considers wrestling and being dominant in both is otherworldly. Terry gets the easy nod over Lee because Lee doesn’t have anywhere near the freestyle resume Terry does. The Brands’ just completely annihilated international wrestling in their weight classes for quite a while.
Had Spencer gone 4x NCAA and won that gold medal match a couple years ago he goes straight to the top of the list zero question. I’m honestly scared for his mental health long term, no joke. He’s been a basket case since losing to Ramos and getting that silver medal, and tilted like a pinball machine since then. People like Lee can’t process losing and it’s not good for their psyche. If he can come back somehow and find a gold in a couple years I think he’ll be ok, but I don’t see it happening to be honest. He’s too deep in his own head. He did just win in Zagreb the other day but that was much lesser competition and the finals was a medical forfeit by RBY, a guy who got his ass handed to him in the Olympics.