Big 10 Playoff Teams

NorthKCHawk

Well-Known Member
There are 6 Teams left that have any chance of making the Playoffs, in order: UCLA, Indiana, Ohio State, Iowa, USC, NW.

The Iowa/NW game will be an elimination game. Even if Iowa wins out, it will need help. NW still has to play at OSU and Minny. Both are long shots, but Iowa has a more realistic path to win out.

USC still has to play at Indiana and UCLA. And needs to win them both. If they win out they are in, but I don't seem them winning both of those games.

UCLA can obviously take a loss, probably two, and still make it in. They seem like a lock to make the Conference title game.

Indiana hosts USC and goes to Washington. They can lose one of those games, but not both. 10-2 (depending on if they get to Indy) gets the defending champs in, even though they probably have a weaker schedule and even less of a resume than Iowa. Defending champs get the benefit of the doubt.

OSU has to win out against 4 currently unranked teams, and all 4 of those games are losable given how OSU is playing right now.

If you are looking for things to be mostly chalky, but with some wrinkles, UCLA gets to the title game with 1-loss. Indiana loses 1-more time. If you are Indiana, I think you are almost cheering for OSU to win out so you don't have to play in the title game. Likewise, OSU should be rooting for Indiana to win our for the same reason. This could be a situation where a loss in the title game knocks you out of the playoffs.
 
That Minnesota loss is going to be a season-long hangover for Iowa.
It certainly makes the climb more perilous and Iowa does not control its own destiny now. That said, Minny has shown itself to be a quality team and that is not a bad loss.

The hypocritical SEC Wonk AP voters knock Iowa out of the Top 25 (from 15th) for a last second loss on the road to a good Minny team, but when a lower ranked SEC team gets whooped they stay ranked (See Florida). The Big 10 should get more respect from the Committee who actually study the teams and their resumes.
 
There are 6 Teams left that have any chance of making the Playoffs, in order: UCLA, Indiana, Ohio State, Iowa, USC, NW.

The Iowa/NW game will be an elimination game. Even if Iowa wins out, it will need help. NW still has to play at OSU and Minny. Both are long shots, but Iowa has a more realistic path to win out.

USC still has to play at Indiana and UCLA. And needs to win them both. If they win out they are in, but I don't seem them winning both of those games.

UCLA can obviously take a loss, probably two, and still make it in. They seem like a lock to make the Conference title game.

Indiana hosts USC and goes to Washington. They can lose one of those games, but not both. 10-2 (depending on if they get to Indy) gets the defending champs in, even though they probably have a weaker schedule and even less of a resume than Iowa. Defending champs get the benefit of the doubt.

OSU has to win out against 4 currently unranked teams, and all 4 of those games are losable given how OSU is playing right now.

If you are looking for things to be mostly chalky, but with some wrinkles, UCLA gets to the title game with 1-loss. Indiana loses 1-more time. If you are Indiana, I think you are almost cheering for OSU to win out so you don't have to play in the title game. Likewise, OSU should be rooting for Indiana to win our for the same reason. This could be a situation where a loss in the title game knocks you out of the playoffs.
Cleanest path is probably for USC and OSU to lose one, Indiana and UCLA to clear the field, and Iowa gets in as the third place team (only one with only two losses).

UCLA could lose a couple, too, starting at Minnesota on Saturday.

I'm not sure I see a 2 loss UCLA getting picked over a 2 loss Iowa. Their signature wins would be a 2 point win over Oregon and a 10 point win against Wisconsin. Pretty similar resume to Iowa - and the Hawks would be red hot and have momentum. I think there would be a slight bias to give Kirk a playoff spot in that type of scenario.
 
Cleanest path is probably for USC and OSU to lose one, Indiana and UCLA to clear the field, and Iowa gets in as the third place team (only one with only two losses).

UCLA could lose a couple, too, starting at Minnesota on Saturday.

I'm not sure I see a 2 loss UCLA getting picked over a 2 loss Iowa. Their signature wins would be a 2 point win over Oregon and a 10 point win against Wisconsin. Pretty similar resume to Iowa - and the Hawks would be red hot and have momentum. I think there would be a slight bias to give Kirk a playoff spot in that type of scenario.
You make a good point on UCLA. If they lose at Minny and to USC, they don't have much resume. Our ISU win is looking more and more quality, and the conference schedule would be pretty similar.

I am not entirely certain that Iowa gets in over a 9-3 OSU team given the head to head and OSU's much tougher schedule. Likewise, a 9-3 USC team would have a win over either Indiana or UCLA. Those are tough comparisons to make.

Plus, while I think 3 teams from the Big 10 get in, maybe its 2? Or 4? A lot of chaos remains in front of us.
 
Plus, while I think 3 teams from the Big 10 get in, maybe its 2? Or 4? A lot of chaos remains in front of us.
Think we know they aren't getting 4. They would love to put an extra SEC team in of course but Indiana with a weak offense, UCLA injury, OSU injury, Iowa weak offense. USC not gonna survive at UCLA and at Indiana. They are not gonna be wowed by the B1G this year and give them 4. Plus Big twelve might get the second in this year out of the top 3 with no Utah QB injury and collapse. Chance that Wake might go for a second ACC if they beat a ranked SMU team on the 14th and then play well in the title game. They are listed at 50% right now. Iowa is at 16% chance of a playoff birth...
1793638241464.png

I think the only team that could get in with 3 losses is OSU esp. if Sayin will return right before or for the playoff.
 
This current team isn’t even one of Kirk’s best teams. Is the league down this year or is it actually a better rounded conference this season and thus leaving more doors open for more of the B1G teams to get in?

I hope we win the rest and get to 10-2, then let’s see how things pan out. Right now it’s really iffy. Before the minny loss we were on the inside looking out, now we’re on the outside looking in and hoping the other teams that are in will fall out and make room for us to get back on the inside. As tough as the conference is this year a 10-2 season is a great year.

I am glad college football agreed with me on my hopes of expanding the playoffs to twice as many teams next season. It’s only logical to do so, especially from a financial point of view and from a fans perspective.
 
Think we know they aren't getting 4.
View attachment 12403

I think the only team that could get in with 3 losses is OSU esp. if Sayin will return right before or for the playoff.
Its not likely I agree. Here is the path.

OSU wins out. They would be Top 7 and that's a high quality loss.
Minny wins out. They would be a Top 20 team and would be ahead of Iowa in the conference standings, but the MSST loss would keep them out of playoff consideration. Still, that is two quality losses.

Illinois (except for Iowa) and Washington win out, which would tag Indiana and UCLA with losses, but keep them in the playoffs. Washington would be a 9 win team and ranked in Top 25. Those would be two quality wins, plus ISU looks decent, and Nebbie and NW likely will be too. Iowa gets in if things fall something along those lines.

A lot of football to be played.
 
If we win out, the Minnesota loss will be used against us, regardless of how they finish. Their loss to Mississippi State and how lopsided it was will fuel the SEC haters in the room.
 
If we win out, the Minnesota loss will be used against us, regardless of how they finish. Their loss to Mississippi State and how lopsided it was will fuel the SEC haters in the room.
I think the Committee looks at a schedule holistically and will see the Minny game for what it was. A flukey loss on the road where the stars lined for Minny and Iowa still damn near won the game. Just about every team stubs their toe once during a season. And, if Minny finishes strong, that will ultimately be a quality loss.

I am equally concerned with getting a quality win on the schedule. Even though Michigan and Wisky were ranked when we played them, they are not now. Washington or Michigan seem like the best candidates. We need someone to get hot and sneak into the Top 25.
 
Its not likely I agree. Here is the path.

OSU wins out. They would be Top 7 and that's a high quality loss.
Minny wins out. They would be a Top 20 team and would be ahead of Iowa in the conference standings, but the MSST loss would keep them out of playoff consideration. Still, that is two quality losses.

Illinois (except for Iowa) and Washington win out, which would tag Indiana and UCLA with losses, but keep them in the playoffs. Washington would be a 9 win team and ranked in Top 25. Those would be two quality wins, plus ISU looks decent, and Nebbie and NW likely will be too. Iowa gets in if things fall something along those lines.

A lot of football to be played.
There is a CFP ranking so the other non-B1G teams who are ranked matter. They have a path but most likely a team will be ranked higher than them in the CFP and go before them. They can do all that and Ole Miss goes in chosen ahead of them or BYU etc. If they do exactly what you state then OSU goes, Indiana goes and UCLA goes and that may be the 3 teams that go. They have to win the at-large comparisons and get ranked in the top 12 in the final poll.

I want them to go but am being more realistic than fan or homer etc. Not seeing how they move up 9 or 10 spots(we need to see where they are in the first rankings) to get to 12 or better. Remember ND should be guaranteed one of the spots as well. The 5 highest ranked conference champs, ND, then 6 more slots from the whole country. It is most likely there will be no spot for them.
 
There are 6 Teams left that have any chance of making the Playoffs, in order: UCLA, Indiana, Ohio State, Iowa, USC, NW.

The Iowa/NW game will be an elimination game. Even if Iowa wins out, it will need help. NW still has to play at OSU and Minny. Both are long shots, but Iowa has a more realistic path to win out.

USC still has to play at Indiana and UCLA. And needs to win them both. If they win out they are in, but I don't seem them winning both of those games.

UCLA can obviously take a loss, probably two, and still make it in. They seem like a lock to make the Conference title game.

Indiana hosts USC and goes to Washington. They can lose one of those games, but not both. 10-2 (depending on if they get to Indy) gets the defending champs in, even though they probably have a weaker schedule and even less of a resume than Iowa. Defending champs get the benefit of the doubt.

OSU has to win out against 4 currently unranked teams, and all 4 of those games are losable given how OSU is playing right now.

If you are looking for things to be mostly chalky, but with some wrinkles, UCLA gets to the title game with 1-loss. Indiana loses 1-more time. If you are Indiana, I think you are almost cheering for OSU to win out so you don't have to play in the title game. Likewise, OSU should be rooting for Indiana to win our for the same reason. This could be a situation where a loss in the title game knocks you out of the playoffs.

Nice analysis indeed
 
It certainly makes the climb more perilous and Iowa does not control its own destiny now. That said, Minny has shown itself to be a quality team and that is not a bad loss.

The hypocritical SEC Wonk AP voters
knock Iowa out of the Top 25 (from 15th) for a last second loss on the road to a good Minny team, but when a lower ranked SEC team gets whooped they stay ranked (See Florida). The Big 10 should get more respect from the Committee who actually study the teams and their resumes.

Evil basturds
 
You make a good point on UCLA. If they lose at Minny and to USC, they don't have much resume. Our ISU win is looking more and more quality, and the conference schedule would be pretty similar.

I am not entirely certain that Iowa gets in over a 9-3 OSU team given the head to head and OSU's much tougher schedule. Likewise, a 9-3 USC team would have a win over either Indiana or UCLA. Those are tough comparisons to make.

Plus, while I think 3 teams from the Big 10 get in, maybe its 2? Or 4? A lot of chaos remains in front of us.

Ohio State has the name recognition to be chosen over The Hawks if they have a similar record

They will draw more nationwide viewers than our mighty Hawks

And they beat the Hawks handily
 
This current team isn’t even one of Kirk’s best teams. Is the league down this year or is it actually a better rounded conference this season and thus leaving more doors open for more of the B1G teams to get in?

I hope we win the rest and get to 10-2, then let’s see how things pan out. Right now it’s really iffy. Before the minny loss we were on the inside looking out, now we’re on the outside looking in and hoping the other teams that are in will fall out and make room for us to get back on the inside. As tough as the conference is this year a 10-2 season is a great year.

I am glad college football agreed with me on my hopes of expanding the playoffs to twice as many teams next season. It’s only logical to do so, especially from a financial point of view and from a fans perspective.

10-2 would be a worthy season indeed
 
Its not likely I agree. Here is the path.

OSU wins out. They would be Top 7 and that's a high quality loss.
Minny wins out. They would be a Top 20 team and would be ahead of Iowa in the conference standings, but the MSST loss would keep them out of playoff consideration. Still, that is two quality losses.

Illinois (except for Iowa) and Washington win out, which would tag Indiana and UCLA with losses, but keep them in the playoffs. Washington would be a 9 win team and ranked in Top 25. Those would be two quality wins, plus ISU looks decent, and Nebbie and NW likely will be too. Iowa gets in if things fall something along those lines.

A lot of football to be played.

Beating #18 Michigan at their house and slaughtering the badgers are feathers in our cap

But even winning out, it will still be a major chore to make the playoffs

I had a very minor cut yesterday and my blood was black and gold
 
There is a CFP ranking so the other non-B1G teams who are ranked matter. They have a path but most likely a team will be ranked higher than them in the CFP and go before them. They can do all that and Ole Miss goes in chosen ahead of them or BYU etc. If they do exactly what you state then OSU goes, Indiana goes and UCLA goes and that may be the 3 teams that go. They have to win the at-large comparisons and get ranked in the top 12 in the final poll.

I want them to go but am being more realistic than fan or homer etc. Not seeing how they move up 9 or 10 spots(we need to see where they are in the first rankings) to get to 12 or better. Remember ND should be guaranteed one of the spots as well. The 5 highest ranked conference champs, ND, then 6 more slots from the whole country. It is most likely there will be no spot for them.
I would bet good money that the Committee thinks more highly of Iowa than the polls do. Certainly was the case last season.

Looks whose ahead of them. Boise? Played no one. Lost to Oregon. Won by a point to Texas State at home. Yawn,

Missouri? Same record. Lost to the same lowly Mississippi St team that everyone is crowing about them beating Minny in week 2. And they have 3 Top 10 games left! The Committee can ignore them. Toast.

USC has had 2 average to bad losses. They are not winning out anyway.

I think Iowa lands at about 18. There are still 4 weeks to go plus conference championships. Just win out and left chaos do the rest.
 
The part to keep in mind is that the committee is tasked with building the best tournament they can. Sure, you have to have the requisite record to even be in the conversation, but there is a lot more to this than just wins and losses, it is when you when and when you lose as well is how you win and how you lose. Games at the end of the season are going to weigh more heavily than those at the beginning of the season. For a team like Ohio State, they are still in the hunt of course, but, they are going to have to show they can still be a good team after they lost their QB because that is not the same team they were earlier in the season. All of the SEC teams that are getting ready to lose are going to be losing at the end of the season and that is not a good look. Front loading a schedule isn't great if you have a young and inexperienced team, but, if you can somehow manage to get through that and come together on the back side of it, that is a huge advantage. We know that Iowa has to win their remaining games, not just to preserve their record but also to preserve their momentum. We started it extremely strong by blowing out Wisconsin and if we keep it going, even squeaking out a win on the road to Northwestern, blowing out Purdue at home to get everyone's attention, then finishing it by solidly beating Nebraska in all three phases, the resume is extremely strong finishing out on a 5 game winning streak. The other thing about Iowa that makes their resume so marketable to the committee is how elite the defense is. #4 in scoring defense, #12 in total defense. That is like gold, especially pairing Iowa with an offensive team, like an LSU or Wake Forest. It all lines up with Moulton out and our run game struggling, we are going to have to win games through the air and if we do, an Iowa team at 10-2 on a 5 game streak with that defense and now a potent offense is a team that nobody wants to play.
 
The part to keep in mind is that the committee is tasked with building the best tournament they can. Sure, you have to have the requisite record to even be in the conversation, but there is a lot more to this than just wins and losses, it is when you when and when you lose as well is how you win and how you lose. Games at the end of the season are going to weigh more heavily than those at the beginning of the season. For a team like Ohio State, they are still in the hunt of course, but, they are going to have to show they can still be a good team after they lost their QB because that is not the same team they were earlier in the season. All of the SEC teams that are getting ready to lose are going to be losing at the end of the season and that is not a good look. Front loading a schedule isn't great if you have a young and inexperienced team, but, if you can somehow manage to get through that and come together on the back side of it, that is a huge advantage. We know that Iowa has to win their remaining games, not just to preserve their record but also to preserve their momentum. We started it extremely strong by blowing out Wisconsin and if we keep it going, even squeaking out a win on the road to Northwestern, blowing out Purdue at home to get everyone's attention, then finishing it by solidly beating Nebraska in all three phases, the resume is extremely strong finishing out on a 5 game winning streak. The other thing about Iowa that makes their resume so marketable to the committee is how elite the defense is. #4 in scoring defense, #12 in total defense. That is like gold, especially pairing Iowa with an offensive team, like an LSU or Wake Forest. It all lines up with Moulton out and our run game struggling, we are going to have to win games through the air and if we do, an Iowa team at 10-2 on a 5 game streak with that defense and now a potent offense is a team that nobody wants to play.
Oh I like the sound of all this.
 
The part to keep in mind is that the committee is tasked with building the best tournament they can. Sure, you have to have the requisite record to even be in the conversation, but there is a lot more to this than just wins and losses, it is when you when and when you lose as well is how you win and how you lose. Games at the end of the season are going to weigh more heavily than those at the beginning of the season. For a team like Ohio State, they are still in the hunt of course, but, they are going to have to show they can still be a good team after they lost their QB because that is not the same team they were earlier in the season. All of the SEC teams that are getting ready to lose are going to be losing at the end of the season and that is not a good look. Front loading a schedule isn't great if you have a young and inexperienced team, but, if you can somehow manage to get through that and come together on the back side of it, that is a huge advantage. We know that Iowa has to win their remaining games, not just to preserve their record but also to preserve their momentum. We started it extremely strong by blowing out Wisconsin and if we keep it going, even squeaking out a win on the road to Northwestern, blowing out Purdue at home to get everyone's attention, then finishing it by solidly beating Nebraska in all three phases, the resume is extremely strong finishing out on a 5 game winning streak. The other thing about Iowa that makes their resume so marketable to the committee is how elite the defense is. #4 in scoring defense, #12 in total defense. That is like gold, especially pairing Iowa with an offensive team, like an LSU or Wake Forest. It all lines up with Moulton out and our run game struggling, we are going to have to win games through the air and if we do, an Iowa team at 10-2 on a 5 game streak with that defense and now a potent offense is a team that nobody wants to play.
Yep, I actually think Iowa would be in great shape if they win out. I don't see a 3 loss Ohio State getting picked over them. The fact OSU had stumbled after losing its star QB would be given a lot of weight - see Florida State getting left out at 13-0 once it lost its QB a couple years back.

I think Dannen and Dantonio being on the committee is huge, too. They are Ferentz guys - I think they'd lean Iowa in any kind of tie break situation.
 
Top